Broil King's stainless steel charcoal chimney. It lights charcoal with no lighter fluid, so there's no fuel taste on your food.
It holds up to 2 lbs of charcoal and has coals ready in about 10 minutes, with vents for faster lighting. It has a resin handle, a wire bail for steadying it when you pour the coals, and a channel that holds an electric charcoal starter.
Stainless holds up to heat and weather better than painted steel.
The less expensive option: Omaha Charcoal Chimney.